Enter your mobile number. We’ll send a 4-digit code to verify it’s you. If your account already has saved addresses, we’ll use the first one right away.
Enter your OTP
We sent a 4-digit code to your mobile number. Enter it below to continue.
Paneer butter masala, also called paneer makhani, is soft paneer in a smooth, buttery tomato gravy with cashews and cream. It is the vegetarian sibling of butter chicken, from the same Punjabi restaurant kitchens of Delhi, and one of the most ordered dishes on Indian menus around the world.
Restaurant versions can feel like a lot of steps. Kunal Kapur cooks the whole gravy in one pot, then grinds and strains it, so it is easy enough for a weeknight. Every ingredient is on GoDirect.
What you need
20 ingredients, the way the recipe cooks them. Most kitchens have half of these already.
Every gravy ingredient goes into one pot together: tomatoes, onion, garlic, ginger, whole spices, cashews, Kashmiri chilli and butter. It boils, then cooks covered for 25 minutes.
Dealu
The whole spices come out, and the rest is ground to a fine puree and strained. That is where the smooth, silky gravy comes from.
Dealu
The paneer goes into a separate pan of butter with ginger and green chilli, then the gravy, and it finishes with cream and kasuri methi.
Dealu's insights
What goes wrong, what to swap, how much to buy. The cooking is in the video; the gyaan is here.
Gravy smooth kaise bane?
How do I get a silky gravy?
Take out the bay leaf, black cardamom and cinnamon first, as he does, then let the mix cool a little before grinding. Grind it fine and push it through a strainer. The straining is what gives the restaurant-smooth finish.
Paneer rubbery kyun hua?
Why did my paneer go rubbery?
Overcooking. In his method the paneer gets only a minute in the butter before the gravy goes in. If your paneer comes straight from the fridge, soak the cubes in warm salted water for ten minutes so they stay soft.
Khatta lag raha hai?
Gravy too sour?
Tomatoes vary a lot, and winter tomatoes in Canada are often sharper and paler. That is what the optional sugar is for: add a teaspoon, taste, then add more if needed. A little extra cream also rounds it out.
Laal rang kahan se?
Where does the red colour come from?
From Kashmiri chilli powder, not food colouring. It gives a bright red colour without much heat. If you want it hotter, add the second green chilli, or a pinch of regular red chilli powder.
Cream ka Canadian jugaad
Which cream to buy here
Indian fresh cream is closest to 35% whipping cream. 18% table cream works for a lighter gravy. Add the cream off the heat, as he does, so it doesn't split.
Pehle se bana ke rakho
Make the gravy ahead
The strained gravy keeps covered in the fridge for three days and freezes well. On the day, warm it, add fresh paneer, cream and kasuri methi, and dinner is ready in ten minutes.
Other ways to make it
Chole has ten styles and every family has an eleventh. A few worth watching.
Restaurant-style paneer butter masalaRanveer Brar · A hotel-style version.
Hotel-style paneer butter masalaHebbar's Kitchen · Creamy and spicy, with tips along the way.
Log poochte hain
Questions people ask
Is paneer butter masala the same as paneer makhani?
Yes. Makhani means buttery, and both names describe paneer in a buttery tomato and cashew gravy. Kunal Kapur calls his version paneer makhni or makhanwala.
What is the difference between paneer butter masala and shahi paneer?
Paneer butter masala has a red, tomato-led gravy with butter. Shahi paneer is usually paler and richer, with more cashews, cream or yoghurt and less tomato.
Can I make paneer butter masala without cream?
Yes. The cashews already make the gravy creamy. Leave out the cream, or use a splash of milk at the end.
Can I make it without onion and garlic?
Yes. Leave them out of the gravy and add a few more cashews for body. The taste is lighter but still good.
Why do you strain the gravy?
Straining removes tomato skins, seeds and bits of spice, so the gravy is smooth and silky like restaurant gravy.
What goes well with paneer butter masala?
Butter naan, roti, laccha paratha or jeera rice.
Your family makes it better?
Send us your paneer butter masala video. The best home recipes go on this page, with your name.